iPad Killer; or Killer iPad


Ok, here’s one of my complaints about blogs on the Internet. Perfect example from the Huffington Post. First, it’s almost the exact same as this February Post, which is even worse as it intimates that Google is working on an iPad “killer” before the iPad has even been released. People complain about Apple Fanboys, but why is the competition so ready to acquiesce that Apple is the standard by which they must compete even when they haven’t shipped a product yet? None-the-less, now that Apple *has* shipped a product, pretty much everyone has made them the measuring stick to gauge their own success. The second problem I have with these posts is that it suggests that a product, that is still in the works and isn’t even real yet, will be the David that slays the Apple Goliath. Let’s see how that worked in the past, shall we?

Here’s an example article from February of 2007, several months before the iPhone was actually released. I don’t know about you–but I don’t recognize a single one of these “iPhone Killers”. I at least recognize the Palm Pre’, which in this article shortly before its release (and the release of the iPHone 3Gs) in 2009 was also dubbed the “iPhone Killer”. Or, how about this article from January of this year–suggesting that, now, the Google’s Nexus One is the next iPhone Killer contender. Yet, none of these previous attempts–or probably future attempts seem to be able to match the reported 8.75 MILLION iPhones sold just last quarter by Apple.

NEWS FLASH: there is no such thing as an “iPhone Killer”, nor, will there ever be an “iPad Killer”; the iPad will succeed or fail entirely on its own merits. AND, do you want to know why?? I’ll tell you.

Pick up a copy of the book “Blue Ocean Strategy“. Then, read it; cover to cover. If you do, it will become obvious as to why no company will ever be able to compete with Apple in these categories–because Apple isn’t competing with them. Apple is creating entirely new categories of products that have never been imagined before. These products buck convention; you can’t have a smart phone that doesn’t allow unlimted multitasking? That’s what YOU think–Apple sells millions and millions of them. What? Unless you have a full OS and keyboard and video camera, you can’t compete with netbooks. Really? I guess we’ll see.

The point is–you are all competing with Apple in markets that Apple created; Apple is not competing with you. That is why Apple products instantly become the touchstone for success–because they defined the market and you are only playing catch-up–trying to emulate and copy what they did in order to make a buck. If you REALLY want to compete with Apple–quit trying. Don’t copy what they do, but show some gumption and identify untapped market needs and solve them. Then you too can be a market leader instead of simply trying to compete with Apple on their own turf.


~ by kizmetkaboodle on April 22, 2010.

9 Responses to “iPad Killer; or Killer iPad”

  1. Good point, thanks for the recommendation.

    Can you please *not* use the dash(-) that way? Use a comma, semicolon, anything-but this.

  2. I dont think the iphone defined the smartphone market, they were just the first to do a decent job.

    The ipad on the other hand is something we haven’t seen before. It clearly isnt a tablet pc

    • I’ll give you that the iPhone didn’t ‘define’ the smartphone market . . . it ‘redefined’ it. Prior to the iPhone, the smartphone market was dominated by devices that were complex, didn’t do very many things very well and really only appealed to the technology savvy people. Apple created a truly, everyday, ordinary-person focused consumer device. The closest anyone else every got to this was the SideKick from Danger, Inc. (and there may be others internationally that I’m not privy to).

      As to the iPad, you’re dead-on. It isn’t a tablet PC. That’s another annoying trend in blogs about it. People don’t know what to call it and so they try to make it fit into an existing category. Not to get all geek or anything, but it is more like the P.A.D.D. used in Star Trek. I think of it as a satellite interface that lets me do a lot of things I want to do while not being tied to my computer or while my computer is busy doing something else. I find value in that.

  3. Interesting stuff. I would argue that apple didn’t make a new categories of product. The iPad is a tablet pc and those have been around for ages. What apple has done through is market it and the app store thing. The iPad has a few unique selling points for tablet pcs; apple fans and it’s app store

    • You *could* make that argument, but I’ll assume you haven’t read the Blue Ocean Strategy then. One of their examples is Cirque Du Soleil. Certainly Cirque didn’t “invent” the circus either; they re-imagined it. Is it a circus . . . sure. Is it like any circus you’d been to before . . . no. The iPad isn’t a tablet PC in the same sense as those that came before it, and that is the magic. The App Store is certainly part of that, but beyond that they simply didn’t constrain themselves to the image of a tablet PC that everyone else has and a new category is born.

      That’s not to say that the iPad will be successful. Their assumptions and different point of view might be completely off and it might fail miserably. I don’t have mine yet, so I won’t comment.

  4. 1st gen products are usually iffy, it is best to let them iron out the bugs. As for companies trying to make a iPad killer, they’ve seen the success of the iPhone and Touch and now they want part of the action. Will the iPad become just a fad, we have to wait and see.

  5. [...] iPad Killer; or Killer iPad Ok, here’s one of my complaints about blogs on the Internet. Perfect example from the Huffington Post. First, [...] [...]

  6. [...] Call: Enough with the 'iPhone killer' | Dialed In – CNET Blogs iPad Killer; or Killer iPad Kizmet Kaboodle __________________ "I will burn down this kingdom, and from its ashes build for you a new [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.